Are Menstrual Discs Actually Messier? Disc vs Cup Guide

We get this question all the time: Are menstrual discs messier than menstrual cups?

The honest answer? They can be, but don’t worry. We’ve got you. 🤍

When comparing menstrual discs vs menstrual cups, discs do sit differently in your body. Because of where they rest (in the vaginal fornix), they have something called auto-dumping, which means they can empty when you use the restroom. For some people, that feels messy at first, but once you understand how it works, it can actually be super convenient.

And the good news? There are simple ways to make menstrual discs way less messy.

How to Make a Menstrual Disc Less Messy

If you love the comfort and high capacity of a menstrual disc but want a smoother experience, here are our favorite tips:

1. Try a Disc Applicator

Our disc applicator makes insertion cleaner and easier, especially if you have long nails or dexterity challenges. It inserts just like a tampon, which many people find more comfortable and familiar.

A cleaner insertion = a more confident start.

2. Remember: Auto-Dumping Is a Good Thing

Auto-dumping might sound scary, but it’s actually one of the best features of a menstrual disc.

When you use the restroom, the disc can empty itself due to muscle engagement. That means you don’t have to remove the entire disc in a public bathroom.

Once you’re done, simply retuck it securely behind your pubic bone, and you’re good to go. No full removal. No full reinsertion. Just quick and easy.

3. Keep Feminine Wipes On Hand

If you’re new to menstrual discs, having gentle feminine wipes nearby can be a game changer. They make cleanup quick and stress-free, especially when you’re out and about. (Check out our newest Rosewater + White Tea Wipes!)

A little preparation goes a long way in feeling confident.

What If Discs Just Aren’t for You?

Here’s the thing: everybody is different.

Some of our customers absolutely love discs. Others prefer menstrual cups because they feel more controlled and less messy during removal. Cups sit lower in the vaginal canal and must be removed to empty, which some customers find more predictable.

And at Pixie, we truly mean it when we say we have your back 100%.

If you try a disc and decide it’s not for you, our 100% Happiness Guarantee means you can switch to a cup or another size for free, or even request a refund. No stress. No risk. Just support.

Because your period product should work for you, not the other way around. 🤍